Supporters, critics of Riviera marina deal launch

efforts to sway voters
 

 

 
By Willie Howard

Palm Beach Post Staff Writer


Updated: 11:02 p.m. Monday, Sept. 6, 2010

Posted: 10:53 p.m. Monday, Sept. 6, 2010

— With the future of the city's marina in the hands of voters, the boat

company Rybovich is campaigning to build support for its plan to lease part of the marina for a

megayacht service yard.

At the same time, residents who oppose the proposed 25-year lease are working to convince

voters that they should kill the Rybovich deal.

Even if the city council approves the lease, Riviera Beach voters will have their say Nov. 2, when

the ballot will include a proposed charter change that would stop the deal.

The company recently hired residents to distribute fliers listing benefits of the lease and has

established a marina-lease hot line. Rybovich Vice President Carlos Vidueira presented the

lease's latest terms to city officials Aug. 25 and answered residents' questions Tuesday night at

John F. Kennedy Middle School.

Vidueira sought to ease concerns about environmental hazards at the proposed boat yard,

which would service big yachts, generally 250 feet and longer. He showed photos of the

company's stylish super-yacht service center in West Palm Beach, a state-designated "clean boat

yard" where yachts are surrounded with scaffolding and shrink-wrapped before work begins.

He noted that weddings are held at the West Palm Beach facility and showed photos from an Earth, Wind & Fire concert there.

And in tough economic times, the city would benefit from the proposed $581,040 in lease

payments and $150,000 in property taxes that Rybovich would pay each year, Vidueira said.

The total proposed lease payments over 25 years: $14.5 million.

The new lease terms would offer more of a landlord-tenant relationship compared with the

initial terms announced in April, in which Rybovich had offered the city a riskier, though

potentially more lucrative deal - a smaller base rent or a percentage of the company's revenue,

whichever was greater.

"We hope we can revive our city together," Vidueira said, noting that the company owns

property in Riviera Beach. "It could really make Riviera Beach an internationally recognized

location."

Meanwhile, opponents launched their campaign to persuade voters that leasing about 35

percent of the marina's upland property and submerged lands on the south end of the marina to

Rybovich is a bad move.

About 20 people attended an Aug. 26 rally at the marina to promote the charter change that

would block the lease. Those attending included Palm Beach County Commissioner Priscilla

Taylor, Mayor Thomas Masters, three former city council members and members of the Palm

Beach County Environmental Coalition.

"This is a community marina," said Lynne Hubbard, a former councilwoman and one of the

organizers of the signature drive that put the charter change on the ballot. "We want to keep it

that way."

Citizens Task Force Chairwoman Emma Bates said the group collected about 5,600 signatures

opposing the lease, more than 2.5 times the number required. The county supervisor of elections

stopped verifying signatures when there were enough to put the charter amendment on the

ballot.

Attorneys for the city and its community redevelopment agency have questioned the wording of

the ballot question, noting that part of it calls for the city to own and operate the Spanish

Courts motel property south of the marina. The CRA, not the city, owns Spanish Courts.

Bates said she will not be deterred by questions about the ballot language.

"If they want to challenge it, let's go to court," Bates said. "We're ready."


New terms for marina lease

The boat company Rybovich last month unveiled a revised version of a proposal in which it

would lease the southern part of the Riviera Beach marina for 25 years for a megayacht service

yard:

  • The city gets a fixed annual payment of $581,040 � or $14.5 million over the 25-year

    term of the lease.

     
  • The annual rent could be increased based on a new appraisal of the property every five

    years, but could never go below $581,040.

     
  • The city could renew the lease for a second 25-year period.

     
  • Rybovich would pay property taxes to the city, estimated at $150,000 a year.

     
  • Rybovich would not rely on city grant money to build its boat yard. If the city provided

    grants to the company in the future, Rybovich would pay 6 percent of the grant amount

    annually to the city.

     
  • Rybovich could lease additional land, including waterfront property at the Spanish Courts

    motel, to expand the yacht-service operation.

     
  • The lease would need the approval of city voters, who will decide Nov. 2 whether to

    prohibit use of the marina for a boat yard. The lease also would be subject to state

    approval for the use of submerged lands and the granting of permits. Rybovich has agreed

    to pay all fees to the state.


[ED. It is instructive to read the Posted Comments left on-line.]